Playbook, private school

Waiting list questions, where the only honest answer is about the process

A family on a waiting list wants one thing the school cannot give them: a number and a probability. What the school can give, and usually does not, is a clear account of how the list works, so the family knows what to expect and stops phoning.

Why this is not the general answer

The handling pattern for waiting lists holds across every trade. What follows is the part that does not.

  • The list is not usually first come first served, and saying so plainly is the single most useful sentence on the page.
  • Movement depends on other families declining places, which is outside the school's control and unpredictable year to year.
  • Sibling policies, catchment rules and boarding places all reorder the list in ways parents do not expect.
  • The question repeats: the same family will ask several times across a year, and a consistent answer is worth more than a warm one.

How it arrives

  • where are we on the waiting list
  • how does the waiting list work
  • what are our chances of getting a place
  • do siblings get priority
  • how long do people usually wait
  • will you tell us if a place comes up

What has to be indexed for this to work

Material behind this answer
The admissions policy, in fullIncluding the criteria that order the list. If the ordering is not published, the assistant cannot explain it and neither can the office, consistently.
How and when families are contactedBy what method, how long they have to respond, and what happens if they miss it. This is what a waiting family most needs and least often gets.
When the list is reviewed or resetWhether it carries across a year, whether a family has to reconfirm, and by when. Families are lost from lists by silence more than by rejection.

The reply

A reply worth copying
The waiting list is not ordered by when you joined it. Places are offered against the criteria in our admissions policy, which the policy page sets out in full. If a place becomes available you will be contacted directly, and the policy explains how long you have to respond. Nobody can predict when a place will come up, because it depends on other families declining.

It corrects the assumption almost every family holds in the first sentence, then gives the process rather than a probability. Refusing to guess is the honest answer and it also happens to be the one that stops the follow up call.

Where it stops

The trigger. Any request for a position, a likelihood, or a change to the family's own circumstances that might affect their place on the list.

The handover, worded
I cannot see the list and I would not want to guess at it. The admissions registrar can tell you exactly where things stand. Leave your name and an email and I will ask them to contact you.

It stops answering before it guesses, says who will pick it up, and asks for the one thing that makes a reply possible. Nothing about it reads as a dead end.

Never say this here

Out of bounds

  • A position on the list, or an estimate of one.
  • A likelihood, a percentage or a typical wait.
  • That a place is likely to come up at any particular time.
  • Anything about another family's application or decision.

Questions

Is it worth answering this at all if the answer is always the same?
That is exactly why it is worth answering. It is a high volume, emotionally charged, entirely repeatable question, and an office giving slightly different answers on different days is worse for the family than a consistent one.
What if our admissions policy does not explain the ordering?
Then that is the work to do first. An assistant cannot explain a process that is not written down, and neither can a new member of the admissions team.
Should the assistant take a message from every waiting family?
Only when they ask for one. Otherwise you convert a self serve answer into an inbox item, which is the opposite of the point.

Keep reading

Try it on your own material

Upload a document or point it at your site, paste one line of HTML, then ask it something only your business could answer.